The Evidence: For And Against

Now that you know a little bit about our plight, let me give you the evidence - both for, and against us. I will do my best to present it well. Ultimately, in any situation involving the justice system, it is up to the system, and the public, to decide what to believe based on evidence - not me, not George, and not his accuser. So I feel it's only right to present both sides. I cannot claim a lack of bias by any means; he is my fiancee, after all. But I will do my best.

The accuser is the step-sister of George. Her father is married to his mother, and despite a relationship full of abuse and deception, they remain married to this day. The accuser has alleged that from the years of 2003 to 2006, George, whom she claimed was living in the same house at the time, would sneak into her room to rape her, at night and while babysitting her, threatening her with knives to keep her quiet, and then helping her clean up afterward.

There are several holes in this story which can be proven. George was not living with the accused, as early as late 2003, and in 2004 he lived many states away. He is not able to drive due to his vision and has no driver's license, therefore he literally would have had to ask someone to drive him to her house in order to rape her. When he lived in the same house, his friend, E.M., also lived in the same room, and of course never once heard him sneak out of the room for any reason. He locked the door to his room to prevent frequent theft on the part of the accuser and her brother and to keep them out. He also moved away because he disliked the family and was tired of their drama. Any time he was babysitting her, he invited friends over, so there are many witnesses who were present at the time and know that nothing strange took place. While living away from her house, when called to babysit he of course had to ask a friend to drive him over - they would then hang out and/or invite other friends over to hang out. At no time did he ever babysit her alone; frankly he considered it annoying and his friends provided some distraction from the drudgery. We have many things like check stubs, receipts, employment history, and so on and so forth to prove George's alibi.

The accusation came about in late January, after the accuser attempted suicide. In the days following her suicide attempt, she gave four different explanations as to why she attempted suicide, according to our witnesses. One of those asserted that George was the reason, and proceeded to accuse him of raping her. The other three don't line up. The stories are as follows:

Story A:

The accuser's mother, who we will call Michelle, tried to tell her that her father, who we will call Buck, doesn't love her anymore and that's why he doesn't come to see her (she resides at her mother's house, and the two are divorced). Her mother attempted to blame her father for her suicide attempt, saying his unloving nature drove her over the edge.

Story B:

Michelle and the accuser's sister texted the accuser the following: "Go to your new family, and don't come back here. We are replacing you, and I am saving up to get my own place." The constant rejection of her mother and sister drove the accuser over the edge.

Story C:

The accuser accused George, stating to Buck over the phone that George was the reason she attempted suicide - this is also what has been filed in the police report.

Story D:

The accuser claims that her suicide attempt was because Michelle dislikes her boyfriend and forbade her to be with him anymore, stating, "You won't be with him in a couple months!" This story is the version she gave to her boyfriend.

Shortly after George's arrest, the accuser called her father 60 times in about 3 days, proceeding to brag to him over the phone that George had been arrested and that she and Buck could be together again. Betty was present and suspected something wrong, and so hid and began to write what she overheard.

Betty writes:

"Buck talked to [the accuser]...and he told her he's not taking sides[,] he told her he's losing his marbles over here and she said 'None of this that's going on has to do with you.' He said 'Yes it does, figure it out. There's your side, and there's this side.' Then he said he's not going to stop for her every little whim. ...And he said, 'Yeah I know about that', and raised his voice and said 'Ahh, I'm not going to wreck my marriage, you have your life over there and I have my life over here!' And [the accuser] said, 'Oh, I'm not that important?!' Buck told her, 'What you do over there is your thing' and she began fake crying. I said 'Oh there she goes with that fake cry just to get to you'. Then she wanted to know when Buck was going to visit her and he said he didn't know."